Drain Pipe Relining vs. Replacement: Which Is Right for You?

We get asked this a lot — “Should I reline or replace my pipes?” Fair question. If you’ve got blocked or damaged drains, both options can work, but one might save you time, money, and your garden. We’re here to break it down for you.

What’s pipe relining and how does it work?

Pipe relining is a no-dig method we use to fix cracked or leaking pipes from the inside.

Here’s how we do it:

  • First, we inspect the pipe with a CCTV camera.
  • Then, we insert a resin-soaked liner into the pipe.
  • We cure it using hot water or steam.
  • Once it sets, you’ve basically got a brand-new pipe inside the old one.

It’s perfect for tree root damage or cracks — especially if the rest of the pipe’s still in decent shape.

When do we recommend pipe replacement?

Sometimes the damage is too far gone for relining. If the pipe has collapsed, is completely corroded, or is made from outdated materials like clay or old galvanised steel, we’ll usually suggest a full replacement.

This means we remove the old pipe and install a new one — either by digging or using trenchless methods like pipe bursting. It takes more work, but sometimes there’s just no way around it.

What’s the cost difference between relining and replacement?

Here’s a rough guide (we always quote based on the job, but this gives you an idea):

MethodCost per metre (AUD)What affects the cost
Pipe Relining$400–$1,000*Pipe size, number of bends, access
Pipe Replacement$250–$700*Depth, materials, site access, reinstatement

*Note: Pricing is dependant on many factors, if you want a proper price estimate just give us ring on 0468 446 852!

Relining can seem pricey per metre, but you save heaps by avoiding digging up driveways or landscaping. That’s especially handy around here in the Northern Beaches — no one wants to rip up their backyard or their veggie patch.

A photo of a plumber doing trenchless non dig pipe relining along the side of a house in Sydney, NSW. The plumber is using a machine to insert a new pipe into the existing one. The background reveals a suburban setting with other houses.

How disruptive are these repairs?

FactorPipe ReliningPipe Replacement
DiggingNopeYep
Completion time1–2 days3–7 days (sometimes more)
Mess and clean-upMinimalOften a fair bit

We live here too, so we know how tricky it is working around gardens, tiles, or decks. Relining keeps things neat — your dog won’t even notice we’ve been there.

How long do the repairs last?

  • Relined pipes: 25–50 years. That’s a solid run, especially if your system’s mostly in good nick.
  • Replaced pipes: 50–100 years depending on materials like PVC or HDPE.

So, either way, you’re not dealing with this again anytime soon.

When do we suggest relining over replacing?

We usually go for relining if:

  • The pipes are under concrete, driveways, or inside walls.
  • The damage is localised (like cracks or root entry).
  • You want it sorted quickly, without mess.

We’ve done a bunch of relining jobs across North Shore and Northern Beaches where the access was tight — saved heaps of hassle and money for the homeowners.

When is replacement the better option?

Replacement’s usually the go when:

  • The pipe’s collapsed or completely corroded.
  • Multiple sections are out of alignment or disintegrated.
  • The original material’s too dodgy to keep.

We see this a fair bit in older homes, especially around the North Shore, where pipes haven’t been touched in decades.

Is relining better for the environment?

Yep. Relining is a cleaner process — no soil displacement, less transport, and almost zero waste. Replacement creates more mess and uses more resources. Not to get too greeny on you, but relining is the lighter footprint.

Can relining fix blocked drains?

Yes — and it’s often the best long-term fix.

If you’ve got tree roots in your pipes (very common around here), we:

  1. Jet blast the blockage.
  2. Inspect with a CCTV camera.
  3. Reline the damaged section to stop roots coming back.

You can read more about that on our Blocked Drains Sydney page.

So… should you reline or replace?

Here’s a quick recap:

SituationWhat we’d recommend
Minor cracks or root intrusionPipe Relining
Pipe under concrete or wallsPipe Relining
Collapsed or severely damaged pipePipe Replacement
Old, corroded, or misaligned pipesPipe Replacement

Still unsure? No worries — we’ll take a look and let you know what’ll work best (and what’ll cost less in the long run).

Local plumber, local advice — from Luke and the team

We’re based right here on the Northern Beaches. If you’ve got weird gurgling drains, soggy patches in the yard, or your dog won’t stop sniffing one spot — it might be time for a look.

Give us a buzz for a free inspection and honest advice. We’ll tell you straight whether relining or replacing is the better option — no sales talk, just local know-how.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

How do I know if my pipes can be relined?

Our team can assess your pipes with our camera technology to find out. We’ll guide you on all options so you can make an informed decision.

How long does pipe relining take?

Most relining jobs can be completed within a day, minimising disruption.

Can Safeguard Plumbing handle both relining and replacement?

Yes we can! We’re experienced in both and will guide you to the best solution for you.

If there are tree roots in your drain can you do pipe relining?

Yes pipe relining can often fix tree roots in drains, as long as the damage isn’t too bad.

About The Author

Share the Post:

Related Posts

Blockages, Emergency Plumbing
Plumbing emergencies are unexpected issues that occur in the plumbing
By Luke Wooffindin
Mar 23, 2025
Blockages
Plumbing emergencies are unexpected issues that occur in the plumbing
By Luke Wooffindin
Mar 12, 2025

Sign Up To Get Seasonal Tips

Get our seasonal tips to save you $$$ on your plumbing!